Fixing Problems

It is rare that two news stories mesh with such obviousness as those which greeted me today.  The headline on the Post described the plight of the homeless in Denver.  They had set up camps that were their only home.  The only persons who were inconvenienced by these urban villages were those who had some interest in moving about the city on public sidewalks, and those who objected to the odor of human waste products in places other than toilets.  Shame on them!  The poor homeless have no other place to go, unless one counts the numerous shelters erected with tax dollars.  Or church shelters.  Or homes of relatives or friends, provided no drugs or alcohol accompany them.  Or their own homes, provided they earn a nominal living.

The other story that caught my eye was about the mass evacuation of Syria.  Thousands of people have been leaving refugee camps to attempt to start new lives, only a few of which will incorporate blowing up their new countrymen.

What serendipity.  On one hand, we have people leaving camps where they lived in whatever shelter they could scrounge, including old tarps, ratty blankets and fires built in abandoned oil drums.  On the other, there are thousands in Denver seeking just such a lifestyle, but being denied the opportunity by mean governmental agencies.  I profess that I am amazed that no one else has seen the solution.  Instead of building new shelters for several million dollars that no one will want to go to, invest in plane tickets to Syria.  Once there, our homeless will be able to live the way they want, free from Denver’s petty rules.  The camps that have been left behind by the refugees will be quite spacious by sidewalk standards.  Administration by the UN and aid dollars from the US will ensure that they have plenty to eat.  The only real drawback will be the lack of cheap wine in a Moslem country, but Yankee ingenuity should be able to solve that problem, especially when the local government is distracted from religious concerns by its campaign of mass murder.

There you have it: the ultimate win-win.  Homeless will be able to live as they choose, Syria will replace its declining population, and the problem of congested sidewalks will become a thing of the past.  Unless some of the refugees come to Denver and end up homeless themselves.

Snakes on an Island

Several years ago, I wrote a letter that the Post printed.  In that letter, I suggested that Massachusetts solve its problem of an exploding deer population by reintroducing some of their former predators.  I pointed out the gains they would reap from sitting in their dens in Boston, sipping their apple martinis, while watching wild-eyed does being killed by ravenous wolves on their front lawns.  It turns out that officials of that state must have read the letter.  Though the wheels of bureaucracy have taken a decade to act, they have now managed to reintroduce timber rattlesnakes onto an island in a state park. 

Although I feel a certain feeling of vindication in this action, I do have a message for the officials of Massachusetts: I WAS ONLY KIDDING!  It was a joke, people.  It really doesn’t make any sense to place deadly poisonous reptiles in a heavily populated state.  Regardless of the questionable political judgment of this state (thanks for John Kerry, folks), I still don’t want these progressives to die a painful death. 

Wildlife officials claim that the snakes will remain on the island since there will be plenty of food.  This presumes that the mice on the island will agree to the arrangement and forego their watery escape route, and that the snakes will never go for a swim to see if there are more tasty rodents on the far shore. 

Then again, perhaps I am missing the point.  Since Massachusetts is home to so many who feel that our planet earth is overpopulated, the state may be doing its part to eliminate excess population.  As a bonus, snakes don’t drive gas-guzzlers.

A Matter of Competing Priorities

This story was told to me by the head of the crime lab of another police department in the Denver area.  I have no reason to doubt that it happened exactly as he related it.

The murder was a particularly brutal, thoroughly senseless, one.  Someone had entered a small store and shot an elderly woman who was working alone.  There was no indication of any kind of resistance.  It appeared the suspect had simply walked in and gunned her down before taking the few dollars that were in the cash register.

When he arrived, the crime lab supervisor tried to organize the search for evidence.  While he worked on the immediate scene in the store, other officers started a canvass of the area.  The shift was a busy one, and personnel were constantly being dispatched from the scene to handle other calls.  The crime scene chief tried to stop this drain of his resources for less important calls.  He was dealing with one of the most brutal crimes he would witness in his career, but was hampered by a lack of manpower.  When one of his officers was pulled because a little old lady demanded an officer take a report on the hit and run driver who killed her dog, he lost his temper.  It did not help his disposition when the watch commander overrode his objections.

When he finally released the crime scene, he had to admit there was not a single clue.  For one of the few times in his career, the investigator found nothing.  There were no prints, no trace evidence, no witnesses to the crime, no one who had seen a car in the area.  The neighborhood canvass had yielded no more, not even anyone who recalled hearing a shot.  He wondered if the diversion of his resources, limited to begin with, had destroyed any chance of developing any leads.

It is impossible, in light of the real tragedy of a life so uselessly lost, to ever say that this story had a happy ending, so let me just say that it had a satisfying one.  Detectives were able to identify a suspect by placing a known violent thug in the area.  He was tried and convicted of the crime, eventually dying in prison.  You see, as he fled the scene, he ran over a little old lady’s dog.

The Political Debate Problem

Anyone who saw the CNBC “debate” on Oct. 30 had to conclude that the moderators were quite biased against the participants.  Ted Cruz was right in calling out these supposedly neutral journalists.  We will see more of the same in the eventual debate between the two finalists for the presidency.   The performance by Candy Crowley in the last fiasco proves my point.  I almost expected her to run over and jump into Obama’s lap.

Here, then, is my solution.  Instead of having an impartial group such as the League of Women Voters, which is predictably left-leaning, pick the moderators, why not allow the participants to choose them?  Each side could pick 4 journalists for the debates.  Those chosen would only be allowed to question the other side.  We would then have George Stephanopoulos and Chris Matthews interrogating the Republican, followed by Rush Limbaugh and Karl Rove doing the same to the Democrat.  This would end the softballs for one side and the insulting sneers for the other.  Each would have to contend with really hard, in-depth, explorations of his or her positions and background. 

Do I think this proposal has a remote chance of being implemented?  Of course not.  Democrats are happy with the status quo, with registered Journalist-Democrats writing the script, while Republicans are afraid of offending Independents. 

There, There is no There

An uninformed observer would have been justified in believing Guldur Zan to be a heroic figure as he stood watching an angry army storm his palace.  He seemed detached, as if he did not face imminent death at the hands of those he had terrorized for years.  There was no way for him to escape, no place to hide, no comfortable exile awaiting this dictator.  As the forces of rebellion breached the outer gates, he turned and walked to the stairs leading to the roof of his seat of power.  Because he did have a way to escape: not through distance, but through time.

As he strode onto the roof, he noted with satisfaction that the preparations were done.  The large capsule that would transport him a year into the past was moved onto its pad and its massive door was open.  The scientist who had built it was powering up the mechanism.  There was no need to exchange words.  Through many hours of torture, this man, Pronik Sil, had never wavered in his contention that the machine would work.  Had he exhibited any doubts both he and his family would long since have suffered agonizing deaths.  Guldur was completely confident that he would soon be a year in the past, ready to seek vengeance against the plotters, most of whom would not even know they were to become plotters.

He took his place inside the capsule.  It had seemed odd that Pronik had made the device so large, but the scientist had explained that it was necessary to protect Guldur from the time waves that might develop.  It had been so well built that even blaster fire at close range would bounce off harmlessly.  This proved to be a prudent precaution, as the rebel force had penetrated the castle’s defenses earlier than Guldur had expected.  Most likely even his personal guard had defected.  He smiled grimly and thought that his retributions would be more bloody than he had assumed.

The first of his attackers reached the rooftop just as the machinery began to hum.  He could see their surprise when they realized their prey was sitting inside a giant round capsule, grinning at them through a porthole.  One of them turned his weapon toward the tyrant.  Guldur was alarmed as the blaster he carried was aimed at the capsule even though he believed Pronik’s reassurances about its armor shielding.  Relief soon followed, though, as he realized the man’s movements were slowing.  Just as the trigger was pressed, and a narrow beam left the barrel, the man reversed his action and began moving backward toward the entrance.  Guldur was elated, then puzzled as the room seemed to shift toward the right.  In a few seconds he would know terror. 

The leader of the squad that had reached the launching pad had killed or captured the few remaining loyal troops on the roof when he realized that Guldur was a few feet from him, sitting in a large vehicle of some sort.  He raised his blaster and fired in an attempt to disable the craft, but it vanished.

“What happened?  Where is Guldur?” he raged.

Pronik raised himself from behind the desk where he had hidden during the brief battle.

“He’s gone.  What you saw was a time machine.  He is now safely in the past, exactly a year ago, ready to seek vengeance on you and the rest of the plotters,” said the scientist.

“You allowed that monster to escape?  He will kill thousands because of you.”

“If that is true” said Pronik “ how can you be here?  He saw you with his own eyes.  You would have been one of the first to experience the tender ministrations of that animal.  So, you could not be here if he killed you a year ago.”

The squad leader was baffled.  “You said you sent him back a year.  Did you lie?  Was the machine really a death chamber?”

“Oh no, I could never have built such a thing.  Even if I believed in murder, I could not have deceived him over such a long time.  No, what you saw was indeed a time machine.  Guldur is now a year in the past. in exactly the same place he left.”

“Then how..what..I don’t understand..”

“Yes, Guldur is  a year in the past, in the same place he left.  What I never pointed out to him, and he never thought to ask, was where the same place was.  You see, a year ago, the earth was not here.  It was a year away from being HERE.  The exact spot where Guldur found himself was in the middle of empty space, a space that earth would not occupy for another year.  I told him that I had overbuilt his vessel to protect him and that was true.  I wanted to keep him alive so he could suffer for years in his solitary cell.  The bio systems could keep a dozen men alive for years.  He could be alive for decades.”

The soldier quietly considered the enormity of the punishment that Guldur had unwittingly consigned himself to, while the scientist continued.

“It will be a lifetime of the most solitary confinement ever experienced.  There will be no possibility of any human contact of any kind, not even a possibility of seeing the outside world.  The horror will persist for an eternity.”

“An eternity?” questioned the surprised rebel.

“Yes,” said Pronik.  “For us, time will continue from this moment.  For Guldur, this moment will be relived forever.  Remember, as you saw him get into what he thought would be his escape vehicle, he was also out in space, watching the earth hurtle by.  He was no doubt trying to devise some way to warn himself not to get into that prison cell.  But he couldn’t.  And he never will.  As long as time exists, there will be another Guldur starting his dreadful journey.  So far as we are concerned, this event happened once.  For Guldur, it may be his first, or his ten millionth, time to watch the earth pass by.  Now, if you’ll excuse me, I need to rescue my family from the tyrant’s dungeon.”

An Army of Melvin

Perhaps it was the extra mug of synthbeer the recruiters gave Melvin.  Perhaps it was the chance to leave the massive cube called a cityment that he had spent his entire life in.  Perhaps it was the promise of adventure in the army.  Most likely, Melvin enlisted because he was unable to say no to anyone in authority.  Whatever the reason, Melvin found himself on a hoverbus en route to a basic training camp within an hour of putting his name on a piece of paper.

Regimentation did not bother Melvin.  He had already been living in an environment where every moment of his day was planned by the cityment leaders.  What he did find disturbing was the alien feeling of sun on his skin.  Like everything else in his life, however, he adjusted to this the first day, then did not ever think about it again.

Life in the camp was a series of evaluations.  One by one, the recruits would be sent to a specialized training facility.  Except Melvin.  The day finally came when the last of his fellow recruits, having failed every test to that point, finally showed aptitude in the mop and broom practical exam.  Melvin continued his daily routine, blissfully incapable of realizing his level of incompetence.

One day, about a week after his solitary life in the barracks began, Melvin was called to the commander’s office.

“Sit down”, private, said the colonel.  “I have been looking at your record.  You have failed every diagnostic test the army has devised.  You are totally lacking in imagination, initiative and intelligence.  You have no introspective ability and cannot plan past your next meal.  In short, you are exactly what the army needs.”

Had the colonel spoken a word that was not true, Melvin would have been enraged.  Since the colonel had nailed his man, Melvin had no more reaction than if the colonel had said, “Private, you are wearing black socks”.

“Tomorrow you will start your training,” continued the officer.  “We have thousands of soldiers in hundreds of occupational specialties.  They range all the way from communications to intelligence to planning to procurement..well, you get the idea,” he said to Melvin, who predictably did not get the idea.

“What we do not have is a combat soldier, one to actually do the fighting.  That will be you.  Our military might is invested in a single machine.  One so powerful that no nation on earth would contemplate attacking us.  There is a problem with it.  Once activated, it must be unstoppable.  There must be no recall, no changing of minds, if it is to be an effective deterrent.  If it is started from the outside, it is possible that a way could be devised by an enemy to turn it off.  If it is started from the inside, a rogue operator could disable it before escaping.  Therefore, the man who starts it must be someone totally unable to even contemplate disobeying orders, who does not even understand that starting it will be his death sentence.  You fit the bill perfectly, private.”

Melvin then started his intensive training.  He was introduced to a simulator for the army’s weapon.  It consisted of a chair with a panel in front of it.  On the panel was a single red button.  The sole action required of him was to wait until he had been sealed into the machine, then push the button when he was given the code words “push the button”.

Over the next few years, Melvin was assigned to numerous bases.  His tasks were few, mainly showing up at the mess hall for meals.  Once a year, he was transported to the simulator to rehearse his vital role in the next war. 

Inevitably, the dreaded day arrived.  Melvin was awakened from a deep sleep and loaded onto a ramrocket for his short flight to his rendezvous with history.  A general accompanied Melvin to the entrance to his craft.  They entered the cramped quarters that would be Melvin’s very temporary quarters. 

“I’m proud of you, private,” said the high ranking officer.  “I envy you and I salute you.  I have one more thing for you.  After you activate the weapon, take this capsule.  It will grant you a merciful end, since there is no way you can ever exit your assignment.  Goodbye and give them hell, soldier!”

Melvin heard the clanging of numerous hatches, closed and sealed forever.  A few minutes later, he heard the fateful command, “push the button”.  He complied and deep within the massive framework, relays were tripped, circuits closed, motors engaged.  Then a cooling fan that had been incorrectly wired allowed an overheated wire to melt which led to a small fire in a critical panel and the unstoppable weapon stopped, becoming the world’s most dangerous junkpile.

Melvin knew nothing about this, of course.  Sealed in the most high tech mausoleum in history, he tried to remember what the general had told him before he left, and realized he had something in his hand.  It was the capsule.  He put it in his mouth and swallowed it.  For probably the first, and certainly the last, time in his life, Melvin wondered about something.

“How odd,” he thought.  “The capsule was green, but it tasted like chocolate.  Why did they make chocolate green?”

The War of the Words

“Mr. Hagstrom will see you now.”

Hagstrom.  The Secretary for Interstellar Affairs himself.  Harold knew he was in serious trouble if Hagstrom himself was conducting his debriefing.

“Sit down, Harold.  You don’t mind if I call you Harold, do you?”

“Actually, sir, I prefer…”

“Fine, Harold.   Now, let’s see” said Hagstrom, pretending to look at Harold’s file for the first time.  “Hmm, you were sent on a mission to the planet *G&&7F# to mediate a long-simmering dispute, but instead you started a war.  Not a very promising start to your diplomatic career.  What do you have to say for yourself?”

“Well, sir, the assignment started well enough.  I was met at the spaceport by our local contact, Mr. Wa$@%.  He briefed me on the situation.  Two ancient tribes inhabited planet *G&&7F#.  They were called the AO5T&* and the L++!? tribes.  The root of the conflict was verbal.  The AO..”

“For goodness sake, Harold, please refer to them as the A’s and L’s.  How on earth can you possibly pronounce that language?”

“It’s a gift, sir.  At any rate, the A’s incorporate many vowels in their dialect, whereas the L’s worship a god named AEIOU and consider it a sacrilege to pronounce any part of his name.  On my way to the chambers where I was to conduct the sessions, I witnessed several fights break out because A youths had yelled vowel-laced obscenities at L’s.  As we drove, Mr. Wa$, pardon me, Mr. W explained the protocol for the talks.  I would first meet with the A’s.  They would introduce themselves, and I was to repeat their names PRECISELY, since the A’s consider their names to be a gift of the gods.  Any mispronunciation or slurring would be seen as a grave insult.”

“With your ability to handle exotic languages, you should have been able to breeze through that.”

“I thought so too.  Well, we arrived and the members of the A delegation lined up to meet me.  As each one stepped forward, he stated his name.

‘H*%po.

‘H*%po, I am honored to meet you.

‘7h>>&e.

‘7h>>&e, may we all walk in peace together.

‘Abraham Li’incoln.

‘What kind of stupid joke is that?

‘I knew as soon as I had said it that I had made a grievous error.  Mr. Li’incoln reached for some sort of weapon on his belt, but was restrained by the rest of his clan.  I stammered an apology, but the damage was done.  Mr. W hurried me out of the hall, and said he would try to smooth the ruffled feathers.”

Hagstrom shook his head and said “I guess I can see that you were truly blindsided.  Abraham Lincoln!  How odd.”

“Actually, sir, it was Li’incoln.  Well, Mr. W came for me in the morning, explaining that he had calmed things down.  Mr. L, well I guess I can call him Li’incoln, would accept my apology if I would simply pronounce his name at our first session that morning.  I was quite relieved that my faux pas could be so easily resolved.  When we got to the hall, however, I discovered that the L delegation had arrived early, and their leader, Mr. ^2w.., that is, Mr. ^ was waiting to meet me.  I greeted him. 

‘Gd mrnng, ^2wd@.  Shll w fnd cmmn grnd fr pc?’

‘Grtngs, Mbsdr.  W cm t nd cnflct btwn trbs.’

‘Then I turned to talk to Mr. Li’incoln, hoping Mr. ^ would rejoin his delegation, but he stayed by my side.  Now I was in a real pickle.  How could I say Abraham Li’incoln without arousing the fury of Mr. ^?  So, I tried a compromise.

‘aBRaHaM Li’iNCoLN’ I said.

‘It turned out that A’s meant it when they said their names must be pronounced PRECISELY and also that poor hearing was not a trait of the L’s.  Both Mr. Li’incoln and Mr. ^ produced weapons.  I prepared to die, due either to blasphemy or dishonor.  They suddenly realized that I was no immediate threat, while a sworn enemy was armed and standing 5 feet away. They fired simultaneously.  Their concurrent vaporizations allowed me and Mr.W to flee as the two peace delegations exchanged murderous volleys.  I ran to the spaceport and escaped.  I don’t know what happened to Mr. W.”

“Mr. W survived and has been sending us reports” Hagstrom volunteered.  “The fighting has spread and thousands are dead.  However, I find it impossible to lay the blame at your feet.  You were placed in a situation that may not have been resolvable for our most experienced ambassadors.  I’m willing to give you another chance.”

“That is very understanding of you, sir.  I truly appreciate it.”

“I intend to send you to the planet Gelnar.  Two factions have a long-standing dispute over, of all things, and animal.”

“An animal, sir?”

“Yes” continued Hagstrom.  “It seems there is a large carnivore named a koorlang that is indigenous to the tropical regions of Gelnar.  One tribe, the, oh for heaven’s sake, let’s call them the A tribe, worships this animal as a minor god.  The other tribe, the B’s, consider it necessary to kill a koorlang and present its meat at a feast in order to advance into warrior status.  The A’s are naturally indignant over what they consider deicide.  The B’s resent having their traditional menu abridged.  I guess you could call this a food fight.”

Harold failed to even smile at Hagstrom’s jest, instead saying through gritted teeth “So I guess I’ll meet both delegations at some sort of hall where we will have a welcoming banquet?”

“Well, of course, you would be expected to preside at a traditional dinner meeting…Oh, I see where you’re going with this.  Yes, the choice of entrée could pose a problem.  Harold, where are you going?  Harold, we’re not finished here.”

Harold stopped at the front desk long enough to scribble a resignation, then ran from the building.  He never returned to diplomatic duty, becoming a midlevel manager at a WorldMart store on Mars. He lived a quite unremarkable life.  They only thing that anyone ever found unusual about him was his curious habit of always signing his name “HaRoLD GRuBeR”.

Global Hot Air

A Skeptical Look at Global Warming

 

Another day dawns, bringing with it more undeniable proof of global warming, or climate change, as it is now referred to. Proponents of this position declare their theory unassailable beyond any doubt. Anyone who questions them is derided as a fool or a lackey of Big Oil. Some of us do remain unconvinced, and have some questions that the “overwhelming majority” of scientists have not answered.

To start with, why shouldn’t the climate be getting warmer? We are, and here all scientists agree, at the tail end of an ice age that will last until the vast sheets of ice covering the poles melt. One would think warming would be a positive thing as it would usher in longer growing seasons, less need for energy, and a flourishing of animal and plant life. Ah, but there is a difference between the warming caused by humans and that done by nature, say scientists. Hogwash! First, there is little evidence man has much to do with global warming. Even if we do have a measurable effect on the temperature, what difference does it make where the extra degrees come from? Warm is warm and cold is cold, and if we get to a tropical paradise a few centuries earlier, so much the better. But the oceans will rise, inundating whole cities if we continue on our mad dash to Armageddon! Unfortunately for that view, the Dutch have been taming the sea for centuries without the benefit of any modern technology.

And what of the scientists who tell us how close to catastrophe we are? Have they shown themselves to be completely trustworthy? There have been leaks of e-mails showing that the most respected proponents of climate change have boasted of their prowess in faking data and keeping any of their research results from the prying eyes of the public, even in the face of court orders to do so. We have seen hockey stick graphs discredited. We have seen studies that confirmed terrifying changes in the earth’s ecosystem, only to see those studies repudiated days later. In one of the most recent examples of this phenomenon, publishers of a world atlas simply erased several hundred square miles of Greenland’s ice cap. Sure enough, a few days later it was revealed that someone had “goofed” and the ice was still there. No problem except for the few panicked Greenlanders who were frantically building arks.

The most telling fact that leads to the discrediting of the scientists is their proposed solution to the theoretical problem of climate change. Even if we accept fully all of their claims, and acknowledge that we are on the precipice of annihilation, what would we expect those scientists to advise us to do? Why, they would tell us that we must end all human activity that adds to the devastation. It wouldn’t matter where it was occurring, or whether polluters received permission to continue their destructive practices. Instead, we are advised by these self-appointed guardians of the environment that polluting is fine as long as one pays other, cleaner, companies or less-developed nations for the privilege (cap and trade). If you are a private citizen and want to fly your private Boeing 707 around, just buy “green credits” from people like Al Gore, who promise to plant trees to offset your wasteful ways. If that is the answer, why not say so? Just tell people it’s fine if they want to drive a gas-guzzling Hummer as long as they plant a few acorns in their backyards.

I and my fellow skeptics are not flat-earth wackos. We are capable of weighing evidence from cogent arguments and persuasive evidence to come to reasonable conclusions. What we are not capable of is being bullied into believing a theory based upon fraud and illogic. So, those who want to lose sleep over global warming may do so. I’m lying in my hammock with my Mai Tai awaiting the arrival of tropical Colorado.

Welcome

Having given up on my dream of becoming this century’s Mark Twain, I still must confess that I have an urge to write. So far, my efforts have been confined to letters to the editor. Although I have had good results doing this, as about 90% of my submissions have been printed, I get no remuneration or other credit. While the Denver Post writers have gotten numerous Pulitzers, the editors have never seen fit to ever even nominate me. Their excuse has always been that there is no such category, but that seems pretty thin to me. Surely a little subterfuge is in order in this case. At any rate, let me share one of my efforts with you and let you be the judges. I noted that a Denver suburb had a problem with coyotes attacking people walking in the park. The city’s reaction: act swiftly to protect…..the coyotes! I wondered how far this nonsense might go, and ergo, I wrote:

SOME ARE LESS EQUAL

Harris was running late. His position as Deputy Undersecretary for Ordinary Affairs required him to continually refine 27,000 regulations. His duties seldom allowed him to appear at meetings when they started, but his tardiness was generally tolerated. This meeting was different. It had been called as an emergency session of the Council of Ordinaries. Not only would his lateness be viewed with extreme disfavor, but the extra food rations that were distributed before such sessions would be long gone when he arrived.

There was hope, however. He trimmed the sails on his pedicar for maximum velocity and put his councilperson flag in its holder. With a good breeze behind him, he could make up a few minutes and arrive on time.

He sailed down the highway faster than he had hoped, and was less than a mile from the council building when he was stopped by a policeperson, who was obviously none too pleased when he realized the vehicle he was halting flew a council flag.

“I’m sorry sir, but you can’t proceed. A woman was attacked and killed by a bear a block farther down the highway”, he explained. “I can’t let anyone interfere while the bear’s feeding, especially since she has two cubs.”

Harris was furious, but he could not blame the cop. The bear was in its own territory, and the woman was the trespasser on the earth.

The cop helped Harris turn around, and even gave a push to the pedicar. He needn’t have done that, using up some precious calories of his daily allowance, and Harris was grateful. Still, Harris would have to use another route and pedal most of the way against a headwind.

He almost made it, but walked in just as the Second Most Ordinary Citizen Whitaker was beginning to speak. Whitaker stopped in midsentence and stared angrily at Harris as he found his seat. Then he began again.

“I bid a fond welcome to all of my equals. His Most Ordinary Citizen Olson has asked you to come here to consider what to do about a most urgent matter. Our efforts to make sure that those organisms having the right of prior existence are well fed and protected, have fallen short.”

The gasps from the audience momentarily forced Whitaker to stop. They found it unbelievable and scandalous that animals might be suffering any hardship. When he was able to restore order, Whitaker continued.

“His Most Ordinariness Olson wishes to share his thoughts with you and to solicit your advice on the proper method of dealing with this crisis. Without further ado, let me ask Citizen Olson to address you.”

Olson arose. The applause was deafening, and continued for several minutes until Olson raised his hand for quiet. Then he began.

“My beloved equals, something must be done to avert a crisis. I have summoned you here to help me decide on a course of action. Since I have thought at great length upon the matter, and decided upon what I believe to be the proper thing to do, I am sure you will all agree to my plan. Therefore, as usual, we will dispense with voting, since it would simply waste our valuable time. Here then is the plan to which you have all preagreed.

“So far, we have been nibbling around the edges of the saltine on this issue. Now it is time to cover it with butter and swallow it whole.”

Harris hated Olson’s food metaphors. The daily ration of food bars was set so that all received enough nutrition to sustain life, with no extra calories wasted on the usurping species of humans. As a council member, Harris did receive a 10% bonus to allow him to perform his duties but hunger was always lurking in the back of his mind. A saltine! Did such a thing exist on the planet? And butter! He wondered what such a magnificent feast could taste like. He was lost in his reverie for several seconds until he realized someone was poking him. There was silence in the room when he returned to reality. All were staring at him, and Olson was silent. His ecstatic moaning had forced His Equality to pause. Harris slunk into his seat as Olson continued.

“There are far too many of us humans using the resources that should rightfully go to those species having the first claim on them,” Olson continued. “We must reduce our demands upon this planet’s food supplies before we cause hardship among the animals upon whom we have intruded. I propose a most reasonable solution. There will be an annual lottery. Those chosen will be asked to donate their calorie-consuming bodies to the greater good. By giving up their corporeal existences, they will donate their flesh to the well-being of our animal brethren. Since no one could possibly argue against such a noble goal, all asked will be presumed to have given their consent.”

As the meeting ended, Harris joined with all present in expressing his agreement with the plan. Each of them felt that Olson’s plan was a brilliant, and quite certainly the only, solution to a problem that none of them had been aware of before the council session. About an hour of obligatory praise for Olson followed.

Harris headed for home. The breeze was now a headwind, causing him to pedal all the way, depleting any energy reserves he had. Nevertheless, he was content, as he always was after attending a meeting of Equals, especially since a grave danger to Mother Earth had been successfully averted. He would have to rest for a couple of days to regain his strength, but it was a small price to pay.

He had slept for over a day when the Neighborhood Proper Action Monitor woke him. Interrupting the recuperation of a council member was not something done for trivial matters, so Harris knew that a matter of great urgency required his attention.

“There is a letter, sir” said the Monitor.

“A letter? You mean a compgram?” asked Harris.

“No sir” was the reply. “A real letter. Written on real paper.”

Harris looked at the object in the monitor’s hand. It was real paper. He wondered what could be so momentous that it justified the destruction of an arboreal brother. He began to feel the paper longingly, wondering just what it might taste like. It was, after all, his to do with as he wanted, and might yield a few calories. He looked at the monitor, and could tell that the same idea had occurred to him. It had been an act of extreme self-control to deliver the letter unopened, and Harris once again felt gratitude to a lower ranking equal. Then he opened the letter and began to read.

“Congratulations!” it began. “You have been selected to fulfill our collective obligation to those creatures having a greater right to the limited resources of this planet. A vote of the Council of Equal Citizens has picked you to participate in an entirely voluntary program designed to increase the calorie intake of those who existed before humans. Since it is such an important program, it is inconceivable that you would refuse, so your wholehearted acquiescence is taken as a given. Enclosed is a pill. This pill will cause instantaneous cessation of your normal life functions. Outside your living area, you will find a container that will contain your recyclable organic being until it can be collected and distributed to needy carnivores. Do not worry about the pill. It will metabolize well before your flesh is brought to the reallocation center, and will pose no hazard to those needy animals who gain sustenance from it. Please walk to the container, get inside, and take the pill. It is that simple to help sustain our fragile planet.”

Harris was stunned. He had thought councilmembers would be exempt from the new program. He knew there had been no vote, since he was a member of council himself, but did not dwell on that issue, as the council had never actually voted on anything. He called several friends to see if some mistake had been made. The first four he called were “unavailable”. Then he called Beauvais, who answered.

“It is a great honor,” said Beauvais. “I wish I had been picked. As for you, all agreed you were the best choice, since you had been so supportive during Olson’s speech and cheered so loudly, he had to stop speaking.”

Ah, brave Beauvais. Harris knew his compspeak transceiver was routed to the Office of Joyous Agreement, and just to speak to him might cause serious repercussions. Harris could read between the lines. He had interrupted Olson, so Olson had decided he was expendable. So, his years of dedicated service to the cause of the planet’s survival were of no consequence because he had dreamed of a buttered biscuit.

There was no mistake. Harris must cease his normal life functions. He knew there was no appeal, no chance to change the verdict. His calorie allocation would stop, and he would quickly die of starvation if he did not follow orders.

He clutched the pill in his hand and walked to the curb. There, as promised, was the collection bin for his remains. A storm had arisen, and he walked in a pouring rain. He pondered the injustice that had befallen him, and began to weep over his fate. As thunder roared around him, he raised his fist to the sky and cursed Olson and all the sycophants who had allowed this travesty, and screamed into the darkness, using the only oath still deemed non-offensive to all, “Dadgummit”.

Then he took a seat in the dumpster and swallowed his pill.